Why do my cold emails go to spam? Five causes, in order

Cold emails go to spam when receiving systems cannot confirm who sent them, or when readers' reactions tell the system the mail is unwanted.

19 November 2026

Almost every case comes down to five causes, and you can check each in an afternoon.

The domain does not prove it is you

Mail systems look for three records on your sending domain: SPF (which servers may send), DKIM (a signature) and DMARC (what to do when the first two fail). We checked 561 hiring B2B startups in November 2026: 88.4% had all three, and 11.6% were missing at least one. Missing records are the easiest cause to fix.

DMARC exists but is not enforced

94.3% of those companies published a DMARC record, but only 65.6% used a policy that acts on failures. Start with monitoring, then tighten.

You send too much, too fast

A new mailbox that sends hundreds on day one looks like a spammer. Many practitioners keep to roughly 15 to 30 cold emails per mailbox per day and warm up slowly.

The list is bad

Invalid addresses bounce, and bounces hurt your reputation. Verify before you send, and write to companies that have a reason to hear from you.

The message gives no reason to care

Mail that looks the same to everyone gets deleted or reported. Reports tell the system to filter you. One specific, true line about the company, such as a job post or a new site, changes how it is received.

What to do this week

publish one SPF record, sign with DKIM, add DMARC with reports, send from a separate domain, keep volume low, and stop at once when someone says no.

We built Reapline around these rules: it writes one email to one person with a real reason, from your own mailbox, few and slow. Details: how Reapline writes to people.

Keep reading

Get back to your real work
We will find your customers

First 10 buyers free, no card

Rather talk to a person first? WhatsAppEmail